Current:Home > NewsInside Clean Energy: Real Talk From a Utility CEO About Coal Power -AssetTrainer
Inside Clean Energy: Real Talk From a Utility CEO About Coal Power
View
Date:2025-04-27 22:17:45
Let’s begin with a game of, “Who said that?” Here’s the quote:
“There is not a regulated coal plant in this country that is economic today, full period and stop,” he said.
You might guess that it’s someone from the Sierra Club Beyond Coal Campaign or the Natural Resources Defense Council.
But the correct answer is that those words came from the CEO of the country’s largest electricity utility by market value, Jim Robo of NextEra Energy, speaking last week in a conference call with analysts about the company’s latest earnings report.
Robo spoke in unusually frank terms about why coal-fired power plants are retreating from the market, and why the remaining coal plants are being used less than ever before. He’s saying coal-fired power is unprofitable everywhere in the country because of competition from less expensive sources like wind, solar and natural gas.
And he would know. His Florida-based company owns and operates coal-fired power plants, even though NextEra is better known as a leading developer of utility-scale renewable energy, and is phasing out coal. Environmental advocates have praised NextEra, but have also criticized the company for its continuing reliance on natural gas and for being hostile to rooftop solar.
One of the most telling indicators of coal’s decline is the falling “capacity factor” of coal-fired power plants, which is a percentage that shows how much the plants are being used compared to their full capacity. The national average capacity factor for coal plants dropped below 50 percent last year for the first time on record in 2019.
We don’t have numbers yet for all of 2020, but the monthly figures show that coal plants dropped to new lows in utilization during the coronavirus shutdowns, with capacity factors falling below 30 percent last spring, which is astonishingly low.
Those numbers underscore the reality Robo was describing, and raise the question of why coal plants aren’t closing even faster.
The answer, as Robo went on to say in the call, is that many of the remaining coal plants are able to keep operating because they are in states or regions with regulatory systems that force consumers to cover the costs. For utilities in those states, it makes more sense to continue operating a plant at a customer-guaranteed profit than to go through the risk of proposing and building something new.
“In Florida, we’ve shut our coal down and we save customers literally billions of dollars of present value over the expected life of the new generation that we’ve put in place,” he said. “So, there is an enormous opportunity. There (are) several states in the country that are not taking advantage of that opportunity, because of some of the regulatory approaches.”
He doesn’t name those other states, but I will. We’re talking about most of the South and Mountain West, plus West Virginia, among others.
Robo added that the Biden administration’s policies probably will accelerate the shutdowns of coal-fired power plants, which he said is a good thing because customers are losing money by continuing to operate unprofitable plants.
One of the most interesting states to watch this year is Indiana, where several utilities are moving quickly away from coal-fired power and the coal industry has responded by trying to get the legislature to intervene.
Meanwhile, companies continue to disclose timetables to shut down coal plants. On Tuesday, Alliant Energy of Wisconsin announced what it called “the end of an era” with a plan to close the Columbia Energy Center, with a capacity of about 1,100 megawatts, in 2025, as Chris Hubbuch reports in the Wisconsin State Journal. The company has said that closing coal plants and adding solar power can save customers more than $6 billion over the next 35 years.
The trend is clear. Utilities have found that they can save money by closing coal-fired plants and replacing them with wind, solar and other sources.
Just look at the power plants that are scheduled to come online this year in the United States, according to the Energy Information Administration. Solar and wind are the leaders by a mile, followed by natural gas.
The usual caveats apply, including that wind and solar are intermittent sources. They need to work with battery storage or other technologies to provide electricity around the clock.
The list of new plants includes nuclear, but that represents just one project, the Vogtle plant in Georgia, which has had years of delays and billions of dollars in cost overruns.
Absent from the list is coal, with zero new plants.
GM’s Big Change: I wrote on Friday about General Motors’ big announcement that it was aspiring to stop selling gasoline cars, trucks and SUVs by 2035, part of a plan for the corporation to reach carbon neutrality by 2040. I got some colorful comments from David Victor, an international relations professor at the University of California, San Diego, who said some legacy automakers will probably follow GM’s lead and others will be much more cautious.
“What I see is the global auto industry fracturing,” he said. “It’s no longer Tesla and upstarts, kids in Birkenstocks smoking dope who happen to be making cars. This is the big kids who are getting crushed by those new entrants, and so you have this potentially complete reorganization of the industry.”
EVs Help Cut Energy Waste: The transition to EVs could save a lot of energy that we now lose through wasted heat, according to this story by Bloomberg reporters Liam Denning and Elaine He. They do a great job explaining how many parts of our current energy system are inefficient, and how a switch to EVs, along with a continuing transition to renewable sources of electricity, will lead to a significant reduction in waste.
Probing Carbon Offsets: Anna Kusmer of The World has a story about carbon offsets, the little-understood accounting practice that many companies rely upon for their claims of reducing their carbon footprints. By paying a third party to take actions like preserving forests, companies say they are canceling out some of the emissions produced by their operations. But a growing number of researchers and environmentalists say that these products are often not delivering the benefits they advertise.
Inside Clean Energy is ICN’s weekly bulletin of news and analysis about the energy transition. Send news tips and questions to [email protected].
veryGood! (3)
Related
- The White House is cracking down on overdraft fees
- Northern Arizona University plans to launch a medical school amid a statewide doctor shortage
- Get Gorgeous, Give Gorgeous Holiday Sale: Peter Thomas Roth, Tarte & More Under $100 Deals
- Man tied to suspected shooter in Tupac Shakur’s 1996 killing arrested in Las Vegas, AP sources say
- Chuck Scarborough signs off: Hoda Kotb, Al Roker tribute legendary New York anchor
- Kentucky agriculture commissioner chosen to lead state’s community and technical college system
- Russia hosts the Taliban for talks on regional threats and says it will keep funding Afghanistan
- Federal agency sues Chipotle after a Kansas manager allegedly ripped off an employee’s hijab
- Trump wants to turn the clock on daylight saving time
- Man accused of locking a woman in a cell in Oregon faces rape, kidnapping charges in earlier case
Ranking
- Costco membership growth 'robust,' even amid fee increase: What to know about earnings release
- 'Surreal': Michigan man wins $8.75 million in Lotto 47 state lottery game
- U2 prepares to open new Las Vegas residency at cutting-edge venue Sphere
- Backers of North Dakota congressional age limits sue over out-of-state petitioner ban
- Justice Department, Louisville reach deal after probe prompted by Breonna Taylor killing
- Georgia judge declines to freeze law to discipline prosecutors, suggesting she will reject challenge
- Michael Oher's Conservatorship With Tuohy Family Officially Terminated
- What would it mean if PEPFAR — the widely hailed anti-HIV effort — isn't reauthorized?
Recommendation
Warm inflation data keep S&P 500, Dow, Nasdaq under wraps before Fed meeting next week
Arizona’s governor didn’t ‘mysteriously’ step down. She was in DC less than a day and is back now
Biden calls for up to 3 offshore oil leases in Gulf of Mexico, upsetting both sides
Virginia man wins lottery 24 times in a row using a consecutive number
San Francisco names street for Associated Press photographer who captured the iconic Iwo Jima photo
Titanic Submersible Movie in the Works 3 Months After OceanGate Titan Tragedy
Call it 'Big Uce mode': Tua Tagovailoa is having fun again in Dolphins' red-hot start
Federal agency sues Chipotle after a Kansas manager allegedly ripped off an employee’s hijab